Shocking Elimination On American Idol Last Night

pia tuscano Shocking Elimination On American Idol Last Night

Photo by Kevin Winter/Getty Images

The silence was deafening……until the boos started. 

In the bottom three last night were Pia, Jacob (another shocker) and Stefano (not a shock).   Ryan Seacrest revealed who was safe:

Then the came the shocking news:

Needless to say, everyone, especially the judges, were completely shocked:

Gotta admit.  Definitely shocked but I kept saying she was not a performer.  She has the best voice of anyone in the competition but the judges kept telling her she had to take it to the next level.  I think America thought she was boring.  I know I did.  What do you think?

Stefano SHOULD be the next to go home…But like Randy said, you never know.

(Audio/Launch Radio Networks)

  • Katy

    PIA is in a league much higher than the others. Something definately went wrong last night. I think American Idol needs to look at their strategy and how the judges give feedback. I really hope Pia benefits from this horrific error, she is the next female star.


    she always sounded the same to me and she wasnt much of aperformer

  • Corné Botha

    i disagree with you Cathleen . the reason why Pia went out cause she is an columbian she isn’t an american. Pia is a great performer . and btw she got a deal from interpola so i don’t care what you say she’s already an idol winner. the majority of americans is racist i say like 60% . allot of them is racists. if Pia was an american she wouldn’t have voted off .

    • Marian

      Everyone has to remember this is a SINGING competition, not who is the best performer. Was Carrie Underwood a performer? No she was not. I remember when I wanted to move her from side to side because all she did was stand there. Moving and dancing comes in time. I think Pia was voted off because everyone just assumed that she would be safe and she didn’t need the votes. She does have the better voice. She is getting more attention now then on the show. LOL! Oh Corne, I thought Pia was Italian and born in American.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Thanksgiving 2015Your Guide To Thanksgiving
Download Now

Listen Live