Well, our panel of celebrity judges have decided, through tasting many of the best pizzas in Pittsburgh, that the Best Pizza In Pittsburgh is Mercurio’s in Shadyside!

Check out the photos!

It was a grueling (and delicious) process, and now it is time for you to decide! Take our poll below and select from among our participating pizza shops & restaurants!

\
Congrats to our runners up: Bishop’s Pizza in Carrick & The Pizza Loft in North Fayette

Celebrity Judges

• Marcie Cipriani – WTAE
• Ashlie Hardway – WTAE
• Mike Clark – WTAE
• Chris Hoke – Steelers, KDKA
• Donato Colluccio – Celebrity Chef
• Carly Noel – WPXI.com
• Rob Johnson – WPXI.com
• C-Love – PMZ, My Pittsburgh TV
• Josh Miller – former Steelers, 93.7 the fan
• Austin – Friend of Bubba Show
• David Highfield, KDKA TV

Click here to register your pizza shop…and get ready to get up early and make an amazing pizza on Friday September 21st!

Rules